← Explore the archive

The rating question

Rate god: the rating scale and the return of voting

How would you rate god today? The question is returning, but new voting is not open yet. Here is how the historical rating idea differs from the index that appeared beside it.

From a personal response to a public display

The original interface let visitors submit a rating on a scale running from −5 to +5. Contemporary descriptions say a participant could respond once a day. A response expressed an individual judgement at a moment in time; the published index combined responses according to the project’s calculation.

It is tempting to read the displayed number as a simple average of everything ever submitted. The surviving sources do not justify that shortcut. The methodology note explains what is known about the old scale and what remains unknown about the formula.

What does a rating mean?

A positive or negative response can have different meanings for different people. It might express gratitude, frustration, religious judgement, reflection on personal fortune or a playful reaction to the premise. The number alone does not tell us which.

That is why we do not translate individual ratings into a diagnosis of wellbeing or a ranking of faith. A future study could ask participants how they interpreted the prompt, with a separate and clearly consented research design.

Can I vote now?

Not yet. The current website provides the historical record and collects newsletter signups. A newsletter subscription does not create a vote or a research participant record.

Get an email when voting opens ↗

While you wait, explore GodIndex, the world rating concept and the historical chart.

Sources & verification

  1. Original report
  2. Contemporary account of daily voting

Editorial review: 6 September 2026. Found an error or another archive? Please contact us.

The next chapter

The archive is open. Voting returns soon.

Join the launch newsletter, propose a research project, or help support an independent GodIndex.